The Old Mill Creamery

Homemade Ice Cream


Monday – Thursday: 11:00am – 4:00pm  
Friday & Saturday: 11:00am – 8:00pm
Thursday: 11:00am – 6:00pm 

The Old Mill Creamery makes ice cream the old-fashioned way, churning rich custard to scoop into bowls or sugar cones, whirl into thick shakes, or sculpt into eye-popping sundaes. Our signature flavors include treats from The Old Mill Candy Kitchen, the bakery, spirits from the Old Forge Distillery, and fresh fruits and nuts that change with the seasons. Sweet!

Our Signature Ice Creams

Oatmeal Cream Pie

Full of chunks of homemade oatmeal cream pies, made with oats ground at The Old Mill.

Banana Pudding

Fresh bananas and wafers combine to create the flavor of the famous Old Mill Restaurant dessert.


Real vanilla beans deliver the wonderful, natural taste of a true American classic.

Salted Caramel
Homemade caramels from our Candy Kitchen create a luscious sauce swirled into every batch.
Whiskey Ribbon

Old Forge Distillery Moonshine meets our Candy Kitchen fudge. So good it ought to be illegal.

Our Menu

We create our featured flavors from seasonal ingredients. Stop by to see what’s new.

The Old Mill Ice Cream Bar
Loading cart ⌛️ ...
Scroll to Top

What Are You Looking For?


Never miss a recipe

Never miss a recipe! Sign up to get our recipes, news and updates delivered to your inbox.